Earned Value Management

Five Sanity Checks I Run on Every Estimate at Completion

An Estimate at Completion is a forecast, and forecasts drift optimistic. The control account manager wants the number to hold, the program office wants it to fit the budget, and nobody wants to be the one who raises it. After sixteen years of building and reviewing EACs on Navy and DoD programs, I've settled on five quick checks that tell me whether a reported EAC deserves confidence or a closer look.

1. Bracket it with independent EACs

Before reading the narrative, I compute a few formula-based EACs from the contract performance data and see where the reported number lands.

MethodFormulaWhat it assumes
CPI-basedBAC ÷ CPICost efficiency to date continues
CompositeACWP + (BAC − BCWP) ÷ (CPI × SPI)Schedule pressure also drives cost
Budget-rateACWP + (BAC − BCWP)Remaining work goes exactly to plan

Past roughly 20% complete, cumulative CPI rarely improves much. If the reported EAC sits below the CPI-based figure, I want to see the specific reason the remaining work will perform better than the work already done.

2. Compare TCPI to CPI

The To-Complete Performance Index asks how efficiently the remaining work must be performed to hit the reported EAC: (BAC − BCWP) ÷ (EAC − ACWP). When TCPI exceeds cumulative CPI by more than about 0.05 to 0.10, the forecast is relying on a performance turnaround that history says is unlikely. It is the single fastest flag I know.

3. Tie it to the schedule forecast

If the integrated master schedule now shows completion three months late, the EAC must carry three more months of level-of-effort: program management, systems engineering, facilities, and anything else billed by the calendar. An EAC that holds steady while the forecast finish date slips is almost always missing cost.

4. Watch the trend, not just the number

A credible EAC moves with the data. I plot reported EAC, the CPI-based EAC, and variance at completion month over month. Two patterns warrant questions: an EAC that stays flat while cost variance grows, and a large one-time EAC jump after many quiet months, which usually means growth was recognized late.

5. Trace the risk and reserve assumptions

Finally, I check what the EAC assumes about open risks, opportunities, and management reserve. Opportunities counted at full value while risks are left out, or reserve treated as already available to absorb overruns, both make the number look better than it is. Each adjustment should map to a specific item in the risk and opportunity register.

Why it matters

None of these checks replace a bottoms-up estimate, but together they take minutes and catch most unrealistic forecasts before they reach a program review or a funding decision. A defensible EAC protects the program's budget credibility, and it gives leadership time to act while there are still options.

Christopher J. York is a cost analyst and project controls analyst in Charleston, SC, with 16+ years supporting U.S. Navy and DoD programs and an ICEAA Certified Cost Estimator/Analyst credential. Profile · Contact